Thescreescore – The sequel to the 2018 hit, Another Simple Favor, has arrived on Prime Video, and the critical response is, to put it mildly, fractured. While critics have given the film a respectable 70% on Rotten Tomatoes’ Tomatometer, the audience score paints a drastically different picture, slumping to a dismal 40% on the Popcornmeter. This stark contrast between professional and audience opinion has ignited a heated online debate, leaving the film’s future uncertain.
Directed by Paul Feig and starring Blake Lively and Anna Kendrick reprising their roles, Another Simple Favor reunites Stephanie and Emily for a lavish Italian wedding. The ensemble cast also includes Allison Janney, Andrew Rannells, and several other notable actors. However, the film’s critical success is overshadowed by a significant audience backlash, raising questions about the film’s reception and its potential impact on viewership.
The discrepancy between the critics’ and audience’s scores is even more striking when compared to the original A Simple Favor. The first film enjoyed a significantly more positive reception, boasting an 84% Tomatometer and a 73% Popcornmeter. While some critics, like thescreescore.com’s Mae Abdulbaki, found the sequel enjoyable (awarding it a 6/10), many audience members have expressed considerable dissatisfaction.
Related Post
The negative audience reaction isn’t solely focused on the film’s quality. The ongoing controversy surrounding Blake Lively, stemming from events related to the book adaptation It Ends With Us, appears to be a significant contributing factor. Several audience reviews explicitly mention Lively’s involvement, with some viewers stating their disappointment in seeing her on screen.
The lack of traditional box office numbers, due to the film’s direct-to-streaming release, makes assessing its overall success challenging. However, the polarized reviews raise serious questions about its long-term performance on Prime Video. Will the considerable negative audience sentiment outweigh the positive critical reception? Only time, and the streaming numbers, will tell. The future of Another Simple Favor hangs precariously in the balance, a testament to the unpredictable nature of audience response in the age of streaming.
Leave a Comment