Thescreescore – The debate rages on amongst Lord of the Rings aficionados: which of Peter Jackson’s cinematic masterpieces reigns supreme? A recent poll throws fuel on the fire, sparking fresh arguments about the trilogy’s finest installment. While all three films are undeniably epic fantasy achievements, inextricably linked within the same narrative, choosing a "best" is a task that demands careful consideration. Fans often champion specific moments – the Rohirrim’s charge in Return of the King, the Ents’ march in The Two Towers – highlighting the subjective nature of this cinematic showdown.
The New York Times recently conducted a poll ranking the 100 best films of the 21st century, and the results have stirred the pot. The Fellowship of the Ring emerged as the sole representative of the Lord of the Rings trilogy, securing a respectable 87th place. This outcome is surprising, considering the critical acclaim and Oscar glory showered upon Return of the King, and the widespread appreciation for The Two Towers.
The methodology offers a potential explanation. The Times’ poll surveyed over 500 industry professionals, each nominating only ten films. This constraint may have led some to select Fellowship as a representative of the entire trilogy, conserving their limited nominations. The list notably features few franchise films, with exceptions like The Dark Knight, Ocean’s Eleven, and Mad Max: Fury Road – each considered a pinnacle achievement within its respective franchise. The Lord of the Rings films, however, enjoy more consistent critical acclaim across the board.
Related Post
Another factor influencing the ranking is the poll’s focus on industry insiders, rather than the general public. A broader survey might yield different results, potentially elevating the Lord of the Rings films at the expense of more niche cinematic experiences.
Ultimately, no single ranking can definitively settle this debate. The trilogy’s brilliance lies in its entirety, each film possessing unique strengths. While Fellowship provides a breathtaking introduction, Jackson’s masterful direction maintains the high quality throughout the entire epic journey. The debate, however, is sure to continue, fueled by passion, personal preference, and the enduring legacy of Middle-earth. Source: The New York Times.
Leave a Comment